We seem to have at least two sides with completely different and inreconcilable opinions on multiboxing.
How about.. we have two different servers? Oter games have different servers based on pvm and pvp (I think). Perhaps this could be a way forward.
There would be:
One server that is identical to the current server, except multiboxing isn't allowed in pvp areas.
Another server that is just identical to the current server.
You get to choose which one you put your toons on.
Imo this would be a democratic way to solve the issue. Personally I think the one without MB would prosper and the one with, would die. But in either case, both sides got what they wanted. My side can play good old AO while the multiboxers can multibox freely 24/7 and they won't have to hear any complaints about it.
Cheers!